Dallas Fort Worth 5.0 Mustang Club

Dallas Fort Worth 5.0 Mustang Club (http://www.dfw50s.com/index.php)
-   General Discussions (http://www.dfw50s.com/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   5w50-ouch (http://www.dfw50s.com/showthread.php?t=2413)

Toby 04-18-2014 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crimson600+HP (Post 69805)
If you heavy road track your car is it recommended to run 5w-50? Just curious, anything to help my overheating problems on the track. Currently run 5w-30.

If you are having that big of an issue with heat which would not surprise me with the large intercooler in front of the radiator. I would suggest going with a larger radiator along with doing a remote mounted oil filter and adding a large air to air oil cooler. That should remedy your heat issues.

We can get you the components needed for this modification if you are interested.

Oh and yes run a thicker oil when you track it. It may not affect cooling but it will definately help to protect the bearings will the huge amount of stress you are putting them under with the power and extended runs at the track.

Disturbed 04-18-2014 02:18 PM

I wanted to jump in and give some useful advice on this thread regarding the 5w50 motorcraft.

Ford is obviously going to recommend their own brand. But this is an "intended use" package on this car, and therefore Ford assumes at least one of us will actually do extreme track work and doesnt want the motor seizing up. Currently, if your a worry wort about your warranty, you can only use Motorcraft 5w50 or you can use the Castrol Syntec 5w50. These as far as I know are the only two Ford will recognize as being covered under warranty due to the specific certifications.

However, UOA's have already shown that 10w30 Amsoil, and even Royal Purple are superior, at least on the analysis sheet. Ford's engineers are not stupid, but what their not telling you, is about the quality of their oil. Under street racing conditions or light tracking, the 5w50 Motorcraft is shearing to a light 5w40 at running tempurature. Under extreme conditions, its even shearing down to a heavy 5w30.

By this, I would rather run a quality oil thats ALWAYS a 30w oil with minimal shearing. Amsoil 10w30 is my choice. And the 10w is soley because we live in Texas.

With a quality 30w, your going to have the same if not better protection, and slightly improved fuel mileage. If your worried about warranty, you can use the cheaper Motorcraft. The same engine runs 5w20 in non track pack AND non boss cars. They assume its your daily driver (the base model), not a race car.

Pick the oil for your intended use, and pick a quality one. :Bye:

Edited for JDMLOL's reading pleasure

JDMLOL 04-18-2014 03:40 PM

5w50-ouch
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 69895)
The same engine runs 5w20 in non track pack / boss cars


They don't expect boss cars to be on a track???

Disturbed 04-18-2014 04:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JDMLOL (Post 69900)
They don't expect boss cars to be on a track???

You misunderstand

The same engine is in all three trims. The oil changes to 5w50 in their higher trims because they expect them to be driven hard.
I think you know what I meant.

JDMLOL 04-18-2014 04:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 69910)
You misunderstand



The same engine is in all three trims. The oil changes to 5w50 in their higher trims because they expect them to be driven hard.

I think you know what I meant.


I do understand fully. I just expected the boss to be the most track-oriented of the bunch...

re-rx7 04-18-2014 04:53 PM

You guys are all very off on your understanding of motor oils.

Crimson600+HP 04-18-2014 06:24 PM

I didn't know that the Boss and track pack cars ran 5w-50 for protection reasons. Given the nature of how I treat my car, I think this is probably the right move to do.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 01:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crimson600+HP (Post 69926)
I didn't know that the Boss and track pack cars ran 5w-50 for protection reasons. Given the nature of how I treat my car, I think this is probably the right move to do.

They do, and they both use the same radiator, and engine oil cooler.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 01:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 69912)
You guys are all very off on your understanding of motor oils.

Hard to argue with oil analysis. But do educate me sir.

re-rx7 04-21-2014 03:18 PM

Study hard.

http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/motor-oil-101/

Disturbed 04-21-2014 03:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70132)

I have been on that site more then enough. Its nothing new to people who want to know about oil. I am more interested in exactly what it is that your questioning about my oil knowledge. So, if your just going to generalize a lack of knowledge and post "101" links... its not sufficient. Let me know.

re-rx7 04-21-2014 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 69895)

However, UOA's have already shown that 10w30 Amsoil, and even Royal Purple are superior, at least on the analysis sheet. Ford's engineers are not stupid, but what their not telling you, is about the quality of their oil. Under street racing conditions or light tracking, the 5w50 Motorcraft is shearing to a light 5w40 at running tempurature. Under extreme conditions, its even shearing down to a heavy 5w30.

By this, I would rather run a quality oil thats ALWAYS a 30w oil with minimal shearing. Amsoil 10w30 is my choice. And the 10w is soley because we live in Texas.

With a quality 30w, your going to have the same if not better protection, and slightly improved fuel mileage. If your worried about warranty, you can use the cheaper Motorcraft. The same engine runs 5w20 in non track pack AND non boss cars. They assume its your daily driver (the base model), not a race car.

Pick the oil for your intended use, and pick a quality one.

Let me ask you this. WHat kinf od wear does that 50 put on an engine at startup?

Disturbed 04-21-2014 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70146)
Let me ask you this. WHat kinf od wear does that 50 put on an engine at startup?

At startup? The 50 isnt as relevant for startup protection as the the first Winter grade number is, and what your particular climate is. Startup engine protection relies heavily on the cold viscosity of your winter grade. Not sure if your attempting to troll or what, because you have yet to actually tell me where the flaw is in said knowledge. If the next response is anything but, I will probably move on to other, more important threads.

Not trying to be offensive at all. But when someone shares knowledge of something they have looked deeply into to help those with questions, theres usually better and / or more detailed responses then "You guys are all very off on your understanding of motor oils." How about you share your knowledge, instead of making a generalized browbeat of others, and leave some details as to how you came to that conclusion.

BV600 04-21-2014 06:35 PM

Great thread I read awhile back on SVTP suggest you 5w-50 users/believers to read.
http://www.svtperformance.com/forums...ight=viscosity

Disturbed 04-21-2014 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BV600 (Post 70176)
Great thread I read awhile back on SVTP suggest you 5w-50 users/believers to read.
http://www.svtperformance.com/forums...ight=viscosity

Thanks for chiming in.
Looks like Motorcraft 5W-50 shears from 30%-38%
Amsoil Shears 1%-4%

Motorcraft Virgin Viscosity to Used Viscosity - 19.9 - 12.5
Amsoil - 10.5 - 10.1

Might I also add that the motorcraft results were from an engine with 3,800 miles
The amsoil was with 38,000 miles

lol... Just saying... Motorcraft is not great oil. Its sufficient

re-rx7 04-21-2014 07:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 70172)
At startup? The 50 isnt as relevant for startup protection as the the first Winter grade number is, and what your particular climate is. Startup engine protection relies heavily on the cold viscosity of your winter grade. Not sure if your attempting to troll or what, because you have yet to actually tell me where the flaw is in said knowledge. If the next response is anything but, I will probably move on to other, more important threads.

Not trying to be offensive at all. But when someone shares knowledge of something they have looked deeply into to help those with questions, theres usually better and / or more detailed responses then "You guys are all very off on your understanding of motor oils." How about you share your knowledge, instead of making a generalized browbeat of others, and leave some details as to how you came to that conclusion.

My point is simple. YOu dont always have to have a thicker oil if your going to be racing. Conditions are the biggest consideration and a thicker oil can do more harm then good in some situations. In my mind there is no need for a 50 in the stang. Wouldnt you agree?

I use a Penn ultra and it is better then entry level AMsoil in alot of test at a far cheaper price.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70181)
My point is simple. YOu dont always have to have a thicker oil if your going to be racing. Conditions are the biggest consideration and a thicker oil can do more harm then good in some situations. In my mind there is no need for a 50 in the stang. Wouldnt you agree?

I use a Penn ultra and it is better then entry level AMsoil in alot of test at a far cheaper price.

Yes I understand your point. This is exactly why I chose a non-shearing 30w for my own car. What you dont realize is why ford suggests the 50 weight. Its because that garbage shears down to a 30 if your actually going hard on the track in the summer time.

They dont expect it to be a 50 at running temp at the track. 50 would be overkill IF it stayed at 50. But it doesnt.

And, thicker oil like 50w doesnt mean shit for startup. 0w50 in harsh winter cold start = fine.
If you run 15w20 in the winter, its just as bad as 15w50. First number is the key for startup. Again, its the winter grade number that determines its cold start viscosity. If Ford's oil didnt shear 1/3 of its viscosity under tracking then they would be suggesting lighter oil. Period.

re-rx7 04-21-2014 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 70183)
Yes I understand your point. This is exactly why I chose a non-shearing 30w for my own car. What you dont realize is why ford suggests the 50 weight. Its because that garbage shears down to a 30 if your actually going hard on the track in the summer time.

They dont expect it to be a 50 at running temp at the track. 50 would be overkill IF it stayed at 50. But it doesnt.

And, thicker oil like 50w doesnt mean shit for startup. 0w50 in harsh winter cold start = fine.
If you run 15w20 in the winter, its just as bad as 15w50. First number is the key for startup. Again, its the winter grade number that determines its cold start viscosity. If Ford's oil didnt shear 1/3 of its viscosity under tracking then they would be suggesting lighter oil. Period.

Obviously. I do believe amsoil to be overpriced.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 07:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70189)
Obviously. I do believe amsoil to be overpriced.

Subjective really... how much is too much for quality? But when compared to other high quality oils, I agree its got a high price tag. Sucks.

re-rx7 04-21-2014 07:54 PM

Well Like I was saying. You can get Penn Ultra for around 27$ at walmart for 5gts. Its better then the Entry level Amsoil for 10$ a qt.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70193)
Well Like I was saying. You can get Penn Ultra for around 27$ at walmart for 5gts. Its better then the Entry level Amsoil for 10$ a qt.

My only comparison is with SS Amsoil... signature series that is. Its an acutal REAL fully synthetic... not one that is just labeled "full synthetic" which started as mineral crude oil and refined so much that it became synthetic.

Pennzoil is awesome oil, I agree. But it doesnt beat the SS line on UOA's.


Also... I did notice how the subject on the oil suddenly changed to pricing.

re-rx7 04-21-2014 08:47 PM

I cant justify paying 10-15$ a quart for minor track days. For 99% of people a good 5w-20 is fine.

Ive owned a many RX7 and there is no engine harder on oil then a rotary. Thats where I learned all of oil knowledge.

BV600 04-21-2014 09:14 PM

Amsoil isn't priced that bad, I can get it for well under $10 a quart. I ran 10w30 SS on my first procharged coyote which seen 200mph, the autobahn, the ring. I used it on my ZO6 also and will be using it on my 14 GT procharged.

Disturbed 04-21-2014 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BV600 (Post 70197)
Amsoil isn't priced that bad, I can get it for well under $10 a quart. I ran 10w30 SS on my first procharged coyote which seen 200mph, the autobahn, the ring. I used it on my ZO6 also and will be using it on my 14 GT procharged.

+1

I am getting my oil for 9 bucks or so a quart through a generous friend. :driver:

Disturbed 04-21-2014 09:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70195)
I cant justify paying 10-15$ a quart for minor track days. For 99% of people a good 5w-20 is fine.

Ive owned a many RX7 and there is no engine harder on oil then a rotary. Thats where I learned all of oil knowledge.

15 bucks a quart? Are you looking at refined liquid gold to lubricate your engine?

re-rx7 04-21-2014 09:25 PM

Ive some oils reach 15$. Amsoil included. I will stick with my Penn Ultra and Wix.

BV600 04-21-2014 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Disturbed (Post 70198)
+1

I am getting my oil for 9 bucks or so a quart through a generous friend. :driver:

I just looked it up I can get the 10w30 SS well under that:driver:

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70200)
Ive some oils reach 15$. Amsoil included. I will stick with my Penn Ultra and Wix.

That's craziness for oil prices, the most I see in my catalog is for 10.42.

Dominic Toretto 04-21-2014 10:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70193)
Well Like I was saying. You can get Penn Ultra for around 27$ at walmart for 5gts. Its better then the Entry level Amsoil for 10$ a qt.

Get mine at $6.00 a quart.

-Alex

re-rx7 04-21-2014 10:56 PM

Damn must be a Dallas thing. I still prefer the Ultra though. The availabilty makes the choice.

Dominic Toretto 04-21-2014 11:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by re-rx7 (Post 70212)
Damn must be a Dallas thing. I still prefer the Ultra though. The availabilty makes the choice.

Can't knock convenience.

-Alex


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:37 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.